When homeowners start comparing flooring options, one of the most common questions is: “What are the pros and cons of laminate vs. vinyl flooring?”
Both options offer realistic wood looks, affordability, and durability, but they perform very differently under certain conditions. At Floors2Day, we help homeowners across Maryland and Wisconsin find the right flooring for their lifestyle and climate.
Our co-owner Joe has years of hands-on experience installing both materials. Here’s what he says about how laminate and luxury vinyl plank (LVP) stack up.
Joe’s Take: Understanding Seasonal Changes and “Floor Breathability”
“Laminates are going to change with the seasons a bit more. We call it the breathability of a new floor in the Midwest because we have seasons, right?”
When you live somewhere with noticeable temperature and humidity shifts, laminate flooring can expand and contract as the weather changes. The movement that Joe calls “breathability,” can cause separation or stress along the joints if they aren’t installed correctly.
On the other hand, luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is much more stable year-round. Joe explains that LVP doesn’t expand or contract as much because it places less stress on the floor’s locking mechanisms and keeps the joints together.
Those living in the Midwest or similar regions find that the stability makes LVP the easier, lower-maintenance choice.
Installation Differences: Flexibility vs. Precision
“LVP is again, in my opinion (better), I’m an LVP guy. I like the installation process with an LVP.”
Flooring Installation is one of the biggest differences between laminate and vinyl.
Laminate flooring is more rigid, which means installers need to focus more on leveling, expansion, gaps and spacing. Even small irregularities in the subfloor can affect the overall finish.
LVP is more popular and often chosen because it is more flexible and forgiving. It can handle minor imperfections in the subfloor without compromising the look or feel. Joe says this is one reason he prefers LVP. The process is faster, smoother and less stressful on the floor joints over time.
Material Strength and Locking Mechanisms
“The laminate board is more rigid than an LVP… The locking mechanism on a laminate is a little more robust than an LVP.”
Laminate has a dense fiberboard core with a strong locking edge that creates a tight fit between boards. This rigidity helps it resist dents, which is why you should choose laminate for your home, but it’s less forgiving during installation.
LVP has a softer core, which allows it to flex and move with the subfloor. The locking mechanism isn’t quite as heavy-duty as laminate, but it is still strong enough for most homes. This makes for easier repair and replacement as needed.
In short: laminate locks tiger, but LVP installs easier.
Durability, Maintenance and Moisture Resistance
“Overall, I lean to the LVP just for the durability and the waterproof and the ease of installation.”
When it comes to long-term performance, LVP has the edge. Here is some information about each option:
Laminate:
- Highly scratch-resistant and affordable.
- However, it’s not fully waterproof, standign water can cause swelling or warping.
- Best for dry areas like bedrooms, living rooms and hallways.
LVP:
- 100% waterproof and highly durable.
- Handles spills, humidity and moisture without issue.
- Ideal for kitchens, bathrooms, basements and entryways.
Maintaining both flooring options is simple. However, you don’t have to worry about moisture as much for LVP, which is better for families with pets or kids.
Joe’s Final Thoughts: Why LVP Wins Overall
“There’s pros and cons to both. Overall, I lean to the LVP just for the durability, waterproofing and ease of installation.”
Joe’s honest take sums it up well: both laminate and vinyl can look great and perform well. However, LVP typically offers the best balance of style, value and long-term reliability.
If you live in an area with fluctuating humidity or need flooring for moisture-prone areas, LVP gives you fewer headaches and longer-lasting results.
Experience Floors2Day’s Shop-at-Home Service
Still deciding between laminate and vinyl flooring? Floors2Day makes it easy to compare both options in person. With our shop-at-home service, we bring samples directly to your home so you can see how they look next to your furniture and lighting.
Searching for laminate or vinyl flooring in Annapolis, MD, Kenosha, WI or surrounding areas? Visit us at the following locations:
Flooring Store in Annapolis, MD
Or Contact us to book a shop-at-home consultation.
